Faith in Fighting: Seth Petruzelli is the Outsider

April 1, 2012
Comments off

Religion and sports have always been interesting bedfellows.

Some athletes like to wear their faith on their sleeve. It’s hard to look at any sports page or website that mentions New York Jets quarterback Tim Tebow without some connection to his religious faith.

In football it’s commonplace for group prayers to take place before or after games, and you rarely see a game go by in baseball or football where a player doesn’t make the sign of a cross, or points to the sky after a big play.

In the MMA world, religion has crossed over fairly often, especially in post-fight speeches where competitors call out to their religious or spiritual figures, thanking them or paying tribute in some way. In interviews, fighters often talk about their faith because it is something very important to them, near and dear to their everyday lives. So why not cross it over into their professional lives?

It was during season two of The Ultimate Fighter reality show when former UFC and current Bellator fighter Seth Petruzelli saw where faith and fighting came head to head. He fell hard on one side of the spectrum, while many of his housemates came down on the other.

“The first time it actually came up was in season 2 of The Ultimate Fighter in the house. Marcus Davis, he’s a pretty hardcore Christian and a lot of the guys in the house were the same way, especially with Matt Hughes being one of the coaches. There’s a scene actually in The Ultimate Fighter house where me and Matt kind of get into an argument for about 15 minutes or so about the bible, and obviously I think the bible is a bunch of BS, and that obviously struck a nerve with him,” Petruzelli explained to

See, Petruzelli is not one of the fighters who talk about God during interviews or post fight speeches. He’s actually a staunch atheist who is speaking out for his personal beliefs or lack thereof after seeing the subject permeate so thoroughly into MMA.

The argument during his time in The Ultimate Fighter house boiled over somewhat because his beliefs did not mesh with Hughes or many of the other fighters, and it’s hard for those kinds of things not to cause a rift.

“We kind of had an argument back and forth, with me coming out on top obviously cause you can’t argue with science. Science trumps faith in all aspects of everything. But they had group bible sessions in the house and I just kind of had a little dialogue obviously with Marcus Davis too about it, all kinds of stuff in the bible,” Petruzelli explained.

“I love Marcus to death and he can have his own views, but it just blows my mind that people can be that out of the loop with reality, and to believe in things like that when common sense just says not to.”

There’s no doubt that Petruzelli’s statements are going to be met generally in one of two ways. Either people are going to blast him for making such harsh statements about religion and religious followers or there are going to be those that agree with him and support his “coming out” about his own belief structure.

That’s where the old saying comes from that you never talk religion or politics amongst friends.

Petruzelli doesn’t subscribe to that theory because he believes that if other fighters are going to speak out about their devotion to a deity, he has the same right to speak out about his lack of belief.

“Faith to me is intellectual bankruptcy,” said Petruzelli. “I have faith in my fighting ability because there’s facts to back it up and that I can fight. Blind faith? Like I said, it’s intellectual bankruptcy, it’s a cop out. Tim Minchin has a great quote about this. ‘Science adjusts its views on what is observed, and faith is the denial of observation so that belief can be preserved.’

“To me, I think it just makes the people feel better. It makes them feel like they’re appeasing some higher life form or some higher God or whatever, but I think it’s something internal. It makes themselves feel better that they’re thanking somebody else for their victory, and for what they put themselves through.”

It’s apparent where Petruzelli falls in the religion in sports argument, but what about the fact that he does fight, compete, and train in MMA, where so many fighters carry religious beliefs and speak out about them regularly?

As Petruzelli explains it, go back to his stint on the second season of The Ultimate Fighter once again and revisit that conversation with Marcus Davis. Sure, Davis and Petruzelli differ greatly on their religious ideals, but it doesn’t mean they can’t still be friends, even if they disagree with each other so greatly on this particular subject.

“We post on each other’s Facebook walls all the time. He posts his right-wing Republican stuff, and I post my liberal agenda on his. We get into some friendly conversations on Facebook all the time, but of course he’s still my friend. Even though he thinks I’m damned and I’m going to Hell, we are still friends,” Petruzelli stated.

“My main training partner, my jiu-jitsu instructor, he’s super religious. I mean, he wears a cross on his gi, but I have a ton of people like that and obviously we get along and we’ll talk about it if it comes up. It’s like that saying, you don’t talk about religion or politics with your friends and it’s really like that, but I think it should be talked about. I don’t think it should be hush-hush. I think people should discuss their views and why they think the way they think about it, and debate about it. I think that’s how learning occurs.”

Petruzelli knows that the subject of religion is a touchy one, much like politics, and there’s a reason so many athletes avoid talking about it even when directly asked about their views.

NBA legend Michael Jordan was famously panned for not supporting a Democratic political candidate in the early 90’s and reportedly said the reason he didn’t speak out about the matter was because “Republicans buy shoes, too.”

Nobody wants to be offensive, or be offended for that matter, and that includes Petruzelli, but he’s not keeping quiet when so many others loudly profess their faith every chance they get.

Petruzelli’s goal is like every fighter. To go out and win, make a paycheck, and appease his fans, and ultimately show that just because he’s religious or not religious, it doesn’t change the kind of person that he is on the inside or out.

“Of course I’m always worried about losing fans. I don’t want to offend anybody. I love all my fans and I hope I don’t lose anybody just because of my beliefs. I don’t feel like that represents me as a person,” said Petruzelli.

“I’m still a nice person. Just because I’m not Christian, I mean, I still donate to charities. I still rescued my dog. I’m still a nice person. It doesn’t change me as a person or my personality. I’m still me; it’s just what I believe.”

Follow @DamonMartin on Twitter or e-mail Damon Martin.
For more
UFC News and UFC Rumors, follow on Twitter and Facebook.

  • mmachoman

    If some fighters praise god after winning, I guess it’s equally okay to praise the flying spaghetti monster. Live and let live. It’s all good.

  • silent_nick

    Never ever ever ever thought I’d see Tim Minchin mentioned in an MMA story.

  • atmosphere

    I hate it when people thank god for their win in post-fight interviews. it’s a slap in the face to their opponent in that they’re essentially saying that god is biased and chose the winner over the loser.

    I rather people thanking god for the opportunity or whatever…or just not mention god at all.

    • fjc1113

      I’m a born again Christian (I take no offense to anyone else’s views) and I used to find it empty when a fighter would thank God after a victory until Bendo lost to Anthony Pettis and still thanked God for the opportunity to be where he’s at. Diego Sanchez (although very extreme) did the same thing after his cell decision loss to Ellenberger. I believe a good percentage of fighters are fronting in their faith most I the time when they thank God.

      • silent_nick

        You seem like one of the cool ones that is getting a bad rap because of the Santorums of the world.

    • TKD

      @ atmosphere: I absolutely agree with your argument. It is dead on! Sadly, your point is lost on most Jesus freaks.

  • pooby

    This seems like a random filler story for a slow weekend.

    BUT, ironically, it was a Seth Petruzelli fight that PROVED to me that there IS a God.

    When he (with pink hair nonetheless) humiliated Kimbo on live national television and stupified all the youtube heads who thought Kimbo was the baddest dude on the planet.

    • doriandardar

      Amen, brother! lol

  • smill0313

    I believe in the big bang theory, but I also know that something had to cause/create the explosion that created space and its infinite size. Whatever created something like that, by definition, should be considered all powerful. Atleast compared to what humans are capable of.

  • brianhussey

    Of course it is okay to talk about his beliefs. When he wins, he can say things like “I worked very hard, I trained my butt off, thank you to my trainers for helping me etc.” You thank God for the win merely because you recognize God has given you the ability to do what you do, given you the will to do it, given you the courage. Not everyone can be a fighter…it isn’t in them. If there is no God and just genetical miracles that can’t ever be explained, then how in the hell do you explain Mozart being blind and able to compose music at the age of 3 ?!? (Sorry for the longer post)

    • silent_nick

      Mozart was not blind. Well, not really. When he was 11, he contracted smallpox and couldn’t see for a period of 9 days. I don’t think that counts. Perhaps you’re confusing this with Beethoven being deaf, which didn’t happen fully until he was 44 (started around 27).

      And yes, “genetical miracles” can be explained. Say for example that 1 out of every hundred million children born will have the predisposition to be able to compose symphonies at age 5. Then consider that there’s maybe a 1 in 100 chance that the parents will be in a position where they can and want to nurture that skill. Multiply 100 million by 100 and you get 10 billion. So in this example, 1 out of every billion people will become a Mozart-type. It’s an astronomical number but it eventually happens. This has nothing to do with God or anything supernatural. It’s just math and probability.

  • TKD

    So, what some of you are saying is that God picks and chooses who gets talent, skill and good genes, while others are damned to being born with down syndrome, cancer, no limbs, etc?

    Doesn’t sound like a God I would want to worship.